scrum blog
Scrum Home Scrum Home
Editor's Blog
Fan Zone
Paper Round
World Cup Diary
Latest News

RSS feed
Editor's Blog

FeedbackFeedback

« Tweet Treats - Volume VIII | | Tweet Treats - Volume IX »

March 6, 2010

Posted on 03/06/2010

It can't all be bad for Goode?


Sharks fly-half Andy Goode has made a headline-grabbing start to his Super Rugby career © Getty Images

I was never the greatest fan of Andy Goode when he was plying his trade in the Premiership for Leicester Tigers and Saracens, in the Top 14 for Brive or on those occasions 17 occasions he was handed the England No.10 shirt but I have found myself wanting to fight the under-fire fly-half's corner since his shock switch to the Super 14's Sharks.

His surprise short-term move came in the wake of personnel crisis at the Durban-based franchise that had seen them lose Argentine playmaker Juan Martin Hernandez to injury and fellow fly-half Steve Meyer into retirement. Eyebrows were immediately raised at coach John Plumtree's decision to sign Goode despite his international credentials because he is not in the same crowd-pleasing class as Hernandez or his predecessor, the equally flamboyant Frenchman Frederic Michalak.

Goode did not help himself by getting sin-binned on his debut against the Crusaders last weekend just a few minutes after coming off the bench in Christchurch. His high tackle on opposite number Dan Carter drew scorn from New Zealand commentators who could not resist the "Andy wasn't very good" pun.

Goode was the subject of more ridicule on his first start for the Sharks on Saturday with the Waratahs providing the opposition in Sydney. The Fox Sports commentary team (including Rod Kafer who was Goode's rival for the Tigers and Sarries No.10 shirt) delighted in mocking his hair ("the only comb-over in the Super 14") and his approach to the game ("something tells me his is not a running fly-half") but Goode himself offered them more ammunition by collecting his second yellow card in as many weeks for a silly ruck infringement that he immediately regretted.

However, Goode did offer a timely reminder of what he can do with a long range drop goal in the opening minutes - a technique no doubt refined in the drop goal-loving Top 14. Despite a key penalty miss in the second half, he did enough to suggest he will retain the No.10 shirt next week for next leg of his five-week Super Rugby sojourn. But things will not get any easier in Canberra where the Brumbies and Wallabies fly-half Matt Giteau await.

Goode would accept that he has never been the most dynamic of No.10s and he has never had the ability to ghost through defences with the apparent ease of the likes of Carter and Giteau. But his lofty position in the Premiership's all-time points scorers list and his similar status in the Top 14 in the last couple of seasons tells you that he will always keep the scoreboard ticking over.

I'm still not a fan but object to the way he is being treated and ridiculed as if he is the flag-bearer for the northern hemisphere in the Super 14 - partly because he is not the best we can offer (they may get a shock is they think Danny Cipriani is from the same mould). I don't want him to take flak from a southern hemisphere rugby community that is still angry about not getting their way over the ELVs.

A little later this year the soon-to-be 30-year-old will find himself back on the Premiership stage with Worcester and Warriors fans can rest assured that Goode will be a better player for his Super Rugby experience and he may well have the last laugh.

FeedbackFeedback

Comments

Posted PATRICK CONDON on 03/08/2010

get your facts straight please. he was yello carded for a scrum infringement near his own line and there was an argument that what he did was not illegal just a matter of interpretation.the ball could have been out when he grabbed for it .

Posted Drew Masters on 03/08/2010

Welcome to the southern hemisphere, where we can tolerate a bit of ribbing without getting all precious and defensive. It is, of course, unfortunate that Andy Goode seems to peronify all that we abhor about home-nation rugby (and it's hilarious that you blame the French for an unhealthy love affair with drop goals), with his reluctance to create anything other than counter attacking opportunities for the opposition back three. All is not lost however. He learnt his trade steering such nigh-on immovable objects as Martin Corrie and Graham Rowntree around the park at Leicester, and may adjust to the more unstoppable force type of back rower in Kankowski. In so doing he may become a more accomplished player just in time to return to the Premiership and be smothered in the wet blanket rugger old-boy network again.

Posted The Dude on 03/10/2010

'I don't want him to take flak from a southern hemisphere rugby community that is still angry about not getting their way over the ELVs.'

You should grow a pair mate and stop being so paranoid. SH rugby has high standards and if the commentary upsets you should you should either toughen up or do something else.

Posted T on 03/16/2010

Rod Kafer threw AG out of Leicester and then moved to Saracens a couple of years after Goode had joined then chucked him out again. Kafer did nothing at Leicester or Saracens but clearly has an issue with the incredbily ordinary Andy Goode.

Posted SH loather on 03/17/2010

can see why shane warne got a hair transplant in the insecure SH. Super 14s rubbish soccer style rugby anyhow - you're better off back in UK goodey!

  Post your comment
Posting Guidelines
 
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left

About
Graham Jenkins joined Scrum in 1999 and took over the reins for a second time in 2006. His journalistic career has also seen him work for BBC Sport and IMG and he currently lives with his family in Farnham. Graham Jenkins
Flickr
www.flickr.com

Upload yours by emailing them to ant75sit@photos.flickr.com

Recent Posts
Categories
Archives
© ESPN EMEA Ltd
espn